Skip to main content

Self-directed violence in psychopathic personality disorder: a scoping review of methods and characteristics

Resource type
Thesis type
(Thesis) M.A.
Date created
2026-08-17
Authors/Contributors
Abstract
Cleckley (1941) described a paradox wherein individuals with psychopathy frequently engage in non-lethal self-directed violence (SDV) yet rarely die by suicide. This scoping review synthesized 142 publications to evaluate whether the empirical literature has tested this observation. Findings suggest that Cleckley's paradox remains unresolved because studies rarely combined a psychopathy measure capturing the affective, interpersonal, and behavioural features he described with an appropriate psychiatric comparison group. Across studies, frequent and repeated SDV was more consistently related to behavioural dysregulation. Affective-interpersonal symptoms generally showed weaker, null, or inverse associations with SDV, with preliminary evidence suggesting that these symptoms were less characteristic of suicide deaths. However, the evidence was limited by inconsistent SDV definitions and insufficient assessment of suicidal intent, lethality, methods, and function. Future research should prioritize suicide mortality, examine overall psychopathy and its domains, use standardized, intent-based SDV measures, and include appropriate psychiatric comparison groups to directly evaluate Cleckley's paradox.
File
Extent
85 pages.
Identifier
etd24466
Copyright statement
Copyright is held by the author(s).
Permissions
This thesis may be printed or downloaded for non-commercial research and scholarly purposes.
Academic Supervisor
Thesis advisor: Hart, Stephen
Language
English
Member of collection
Download file Size
etd24466.pdf 1.19 MB