Resource type
Date created
2026-02-01
Authors/Contributors
Author: Memarian, Bahar
Author: Doleck, Tenzin
Abstract
This systematic review critically analyzes the contexts and challenges of Levels of automation (LOA), particularly in light of advancements by Artificial Intelligence (AI). The field of Human Automation Interaction (HAI) aims to better understand how automating tasks can be understood by humans who today are more likely out of the loop. A crucial framework used in this field is the LOA framework, which aims to characterize human operators' and automated machines' roles and capabilities. The traditional fields of HAI are recently experiencing more rapid integration of AI, hence requiring a deeper investigation of the recent state of LOA. A systematic review of literature (N=118) is conducted to examine: What research demographics, contexts, and challenges are reported with the LOA in the literature? Data analysis, data extraction, and open and axial coding were employed, and consensus was reached by iterative discussion between the authors. This resulted in a total of 118 studies included in the review. The review informed six categories of context and 26 codes of challenges. The most frequent challenges were increased LOA and decreased objectives, such as situation awareness. The most frequent difficulties per theme were further discussed. This work covers a comprehensive analysis of the changing landscape and landslides of HAI. The contribution of this work is to outline weaknesses embedded in research with LOA and suggesting a reform with prospects of enhanced HAI with AI. This research further contributes to the conceptualization and revision of LOA in light of emerging AI by analyzing the papers that share contexts/applications of LOA and challenges.
Document
Copyright statement
Copyright is held by the author(s).
Scholarly level
Member of collection
| Download file | Size |
|---|---|
| ManuscriptMemarian-Doleck.pdf | 661.18 KB |