Resource type
Date created
2023-08
Authors/Contributors
Author: Schwartz, Christine
Author: Waddell, Charlotte
Author: Barican, Jen
Author: Yung, Donna
Author: Gray-Grant, Daphne
Abstract
Background: Approximately 26.5 percent of children who meet diagnostic criteria for one mental disorder, meet criteria for two or more. Children with multiple disorders often face added challenges, including poorer quality of life and more peer problems. To better assist these young people, we set out to identify effective interventions for treating co-occurring disorders.
Methods: We used systematic review methods to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating treatments designed to address two disorders in a single intervention. After applying our rigorous inclusion criteria, we accepted five RCTs evaluating three treatments.
Results: The effects of the interventions were mixed. Both Brief Behavioral Therapy for anxiety and depression and Risk Reduction through Family Therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and substance use resulted in some symptom reduction. Multidimensional Family Therapy, which aimed to reduce substance use disorders and behaviour problems, similarly showed mixed outcomes. In one of three RCTs, substance use was reduced while in all three RCTs there were at least one indicator of reductions in behaviour concerns.
Conclusions: Transdiagnostic treatments can be effective for young people experiencing co-occurring disorders, including for symptoms of anxiety, behaviour problems, substance use and PTSD. Given the “double” challenges facing young people with co-occurring mental disorders building capacity to address them is essential.
Methods: We used systematic review methods to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) evaluating treatments designed to address two disorders in a single intervention. After applying our rigorous inclusion criteria, we accepted five RCTs evaluating three treatments.
Results: The effects of the interventions were mixed. Both Brief Behavioral Therapy for anxiety and depression and Risk Reduction through Family Therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and substance use resulted in some symptom reduction. Multidimensional Family Therapy, which aimed to reduce substance use disorders and behaviour problems, similarly showed mixed outcomes. In one of three RCTs, substance use was reduced while in all three RCTs there were at least one indicator of reductions in behaviour concerns.
Conclusions: Transdiagnostic treatments can be effective for young people experiencing co-occurring disorders, including for symptoms of anxiety, behaviour problems, substance use and PTSD. Given the “double” challenges facing young people with co-occurring mental disorders building capacity to address them is essential.
Document
Publication details
Publication title
Children’s Mental Health Research Quarterly
Document title
Treating concurrent mental disorders in children
Publisher
Children’s Health Policy Centre, Simon Fraser University
Date
2023-08
Volume
17
Issue
3
First page
1
Last page
16
Published article URL
Copyright statement
Copyright is held by the author(s).
Scholarly level
Peer reviewed?
Yes
Member of collection
Download file | Size |
---|---|
RQ-17-03-Summer.pdf | 1.21 MB |