A sentence completion measure of Kohut and Wolf's narcissistic personality types

Resource type
Thesis type
((Thesis)/(Dissertation)) Ph.D.
Date created
2003
Authors/Contributors
Abstract
The present study reconstructed a Sentence Completion test and scoring manual (Estrin, 1994) originally designed to measure K ohut and W olfs (1978) mirror-hungry, ideal-hungry, and twinship-hungry subclinical narcissistic personalities in a student sample. In order to extend the test’s range, 140 student and 20 psychotherapy client participants were recruited. Operational definitions were revised and subscales constructed according to theory-driven rules, resulting in a 24-item test with 3 subscales representing the behavioral expression o f the narcissistic need (ml, H, t1), and 3 representing narcissistic vulnerability (m2, i2, t2). Inter-rater reliability was satisfactory for all subscales except H. Student participants demonstrated greater idealhunger and grandiose narcissism. Females scored higher than males on narcissistic vulnerability. An analysis o f scoring patterns determined that, as expected, mirror-hunger was most prevalent, and twinship-hunger the least. A principal components analysis resulted in 4 oblique factors, suggesting both vulnerable and grandiose mirror-hungry narcissism, and the attraction and disappointment dynamics underlying twinship-hunger. Aggregated content validity findings were consistent with theoretical models for mirror- and twinship-hunger, but not ideal-hunger. All subscales except H demonstrated convergence with self-rating measures o f the personality constructs, but predicted associations between subscales and corresponding other-rating scales co m p leted by therapists o f clinical participants w ere n o t supported. Convergent validity was not demonstrated for the H subscale, whereas i2 was related to defensiveness. Twinship-hungry scales were related to dependency and reassurance-seeking (for t1), and risk-avoidance (for t2). The combination o f the m l and m2 subscales conformed to K ohut & W olfs (1978) description o f the mirror-hungry type as being both attention- and recognition-seeking, and defensive. As predicted, the m l (attention-seeking) subscale was relat d to overt narcissism, whereas the m2 (vulnerability) subscale was associated with both overt and covert characteristics. Product term multiple regression analyses were inconclusive in attempting to demonstrate: a) that the low m l / high m2 scoring profile was related to covert narcissism, and b) that narcissistic vulnerability (as manifested by the high m l / high m2 scoring profile) was associated with overt narcissism. However, cumulative evidence suggested a relationship between overt narcissism and narcissistic vulnerability. Overall findings supported the validity o f the mirror-hungry scale as a measure o f exhibitionistic-vulnerable subclinical narcissism.
Document
Copyright statement
Copyright is held by the author.
Permissions
The author granted permission for the file to be printed and for the text to be copied and pasted.
Scholarly level
Supervisor or Senior Supervisor
Thesis advisor: Marcia, James
Language
English
Member of collection
Attachment Size
Estrin2003.pdf 11.32 MB