Design, Analysis, and Presentation of Crossover Trials

Resource type
Date created
2009
Authors/Contributors
Author: Chan, An-Wen
Author: Wu, Ping
Author: Vail, Andy
Abstract
Objective:Although crossover trials enjoy wide use, standards for analysis and reporting have notbeen established. We reviewed methodological aspects and quality of reporting in a representativesample of published crossover trials.Methods:We searched MEDLINE for December 2000 and identified all randomized crossovertrials. We abstracted data independently, in duplicate, on 14 design criteria, 13 analysis criteria, and14 criteria assessing the data presentation.Results:We identified 526 randomized controlled trials, of which 116 were crossover trials. Trialswere drug efficacy (48%), pharmacokinetic (28%), and nonpharmacologic (30%). The median samplesize was 15 (interquartile range 8–38). Most (72%) trials used 2 treatments and had 2 periods (64%).Few trials reported allocation concealment (17%) or sequence generation (7%). Only 20% of trialsreported a sample size calculation and only 31% of these considered pairing of data in thecalculation. Carry-over issues were addressed in 29% of trial's methods. Most trials reported anddefended a washout period (70%). Almost all trials (93%) tested for treatment effects using paireddata and also presented details on by-group results (95%). Only 29% presented CIs or SE so thatdata could be entered into a meta-analysis.Conclusion:Reports of crossover trials frequently omit important methodological issues indesign, analysis, and presentation. Guidelines for the conduct and reporting of crossover trialsmight improve the conduct and reporting of studies using this important trial design.
Document
Published as
Trials 2009, 10:27 doi:10.1186/1745-6215-10-27
Publication title
Trials
Document title
Design, Analysis, and Presentation of Crossover Trials
Date
2009
Volume
10
Issue
27
Publisher DOI
10.1186/1745-6215-10-27
Copyright statement
Copyright is held by the author(s).
Scholarly level
Peer reviewed?
Yes
Language
Member of collection
Attachment Size
1745-6215-10-27.pdf 222.71 KB